Beef Certifications Explained

Labels, grades, and certifications can be confusing. Here's what they actually mean—and which ones matter.

The Bulk Beef Reality

When you buy a half or quarter cow from a local farm, the meat is typically processed under the Custom Exemption—meaning you own the animal before slaughter. This meat won't have USDA grades, organic seals, or most retail certifications. That's normal. Quality assurance shifts from federal stamps to your relationship with the farmer.

USDA Quality Grades

USDA grading measures marbling and maturity to predict tenderness and flavor. It's voluntary—packers pay for it. Most bulk beef is ungraded, not because it's low quality, but because small processors can't afford it.

Prime

Top 3% of beef. Abundant marbling, young cattle. Usually goes to high-end restaurants. Rarely available in bulk buying.

Choice

The benchmark for quality retail beef. Good marbling, tender. What you're likely getting from a well-managed farm with grain-finished cattle.

Select

Leaner with less marbling. Fine for marinating or braising, but less forgiving if overcooked. Common in grass-finished beef.

Certifications That Mean Something

USDA Organic

No antibiotics or hormones ever. 100% organic feed (no GMOs, synthetic fertilizers). Outdoor access required, 30% of diet from pasture during grazing season.

Caveat: Organic cattle can still be finished in feedlots with organic grain. "Organic" doesn't mean grass-fed.

American Grassfed Association (AGA)

100% grass and forage from weaning to harvest—no grain, ever. No antibiotics or hormones. Animals on pasture, feedlots prohibited. Born and raised in USA.

The gold standard for grass-fed verification. Third-party audited.

Animal Welfare Approved (AWA)

Continuous pasture access for life. Feedlots strictly prohibited. No dehorning. Pain relief required for castration. Every farm audited annually.

Rated "Excellent" by Consumer Reports. The highest bar for animal welfare.

Certified Humane

Improves on industry baselines but doesn't require pasture access (unless "Free Range" labeled). Feedlots permitted with space and enrichment requirements.

A realistic middle ground—better than conventional, but not the highest standard.

Global Animal Partnership (GAP)

5-step rating system. Step 1 is barely above conventional. Step 4+ requires 75%+ time on pasture. Step 5 means continuous pasture, no physical alterations.

Always check the step number. GAP Step 1 is vastly different from Step 5.

Labels That Mean Almost Nothing

These terms have no rigorous standards or are approved based on simple paperwork, not audits:

"Natural"

Only means no artificial ingredients in the final product. Says nothing about raising practices.

"Pasture-Raised"

No legal definition. Could mean full-time pasture or just occasional access.

"Humanely Raised"

No legal standard. Approved based on producer's own explanation.

"Sustainable"

No codified definition. Can mean almost anything.

"Hormone-Free"

All pork and chicken are hormone-free by law anyway. For beef, "No Added Hormones" is the approved term.

"Local"

Geographic only (400 miles or same state). Says nothing about quality or practices.

Questions to Ask Your Farmer

When buying direct, your "audit" is the conversation. Here's what to ask:

Question	What to Listen For
"Is it grass-finished or grain-finished?"	Both are valid—just know which you're getting. Grain = milder, fattier. Grass = leaner, earthier.
"How long is the carcass dry-aged?"	14-21 days is standard for tenderness. Less than 10 days often means tougher meat.
"What's your sick animal protocol?"	Honest answer: "We treat them and sell at auction, not to customers." Red flag: "We never have sick animals."
"Is the price per hanging weight or cut weight?"	Hanging weight is standard. You'll take home 60-65% of what you pay for. Always clarify.

Certification Questions

Why doesn't my local farm beef have a USDA grade?

USDA grading is voluntary and expensive. Graders charge hourly rates, and bringing one to a small processor for 5 cows would add hundreds of dollars per animal. Custom-exempt beef (what you get when buying a share) is inspected for safety but typically not graded. The absence of a grade reflects economics, not quality.

Is "Natural" beef better than regular beef?

No. "Natural" only means no artificial ingredients or added color in the final product—it says nothing about how the animal was raised. A feedlot cow given hormones and antibiotics can still be labeled "Natural" if the meat isn't dyed or flavored. It's essentially meaningless for production practices.

What's the difference between "grass-fed" and "grass-finished"?

Since the USDA withdrew its grass-fed standard in 2016, "grass-fed" has no strict definition. An animal could eat grass most of its life but be finished on grain and still be called "grass-fed." "Grass-finished" or "100% grass-fed" means grass only, no grain ever. For verification, look for American Grassfed Association (AGA) certification.

Which certifications are actually worth paying for?

Animal Welfare Approved (AWA) is the gold standard for welfare—every farm is audited annually. American Grassfed Association (AGA) is the most rigorous for diet claims. USDA Organic guarantees no antibiotics, hormones, or synthetic inputs. Certified Humane is a solid middle ground. GAP Step 4+ means real pasture access. Most other labels are marketing.

Can I resell meat I buy from a farm?

No. Custom-exempt meat is stamped "NOT FOR SALE" and is legally only for your household, non-paying guests, and employees. Selling individual cuts from a custom-exempt animal is a federal crime. If you want to resell, the animal must be slaughtered under USDA or state inspection.

Ready to find a supplier?

Browse farms and ask about their practices directly.

Browse Suppliers